Allison's problems were just beginning. After an argument with her father, she goes looking for Mr. Molly, her cat. Instead of finding him, she finds a dead body in the pump house. She runs to get her father and when they return, the pump house is empty. When Allison and her best friend Trish set out to find the disappearing body, they encounter more strange happenings at the ranch. Mysteriously a light turns on in the barn and when the girls investigate noises inside, they find the barn empty. Determined to solve the puzzle, Allison and Trish enlist the aid of Robert and Brad. Just when the four get close to finding the answer, the boys disappear. Trish goes for help and Allison is left on her. Things couldn't get spookier, she thinks . . . until she hears something in the cellar.